Tuesday, September 24, 2013

Ten Great Operatic Basses

Top Ten Bass Singers
    Samuel Ramey
Ferruccio Furlanetto
Pol Plancon
Ezio Pinza
Evgeny Nesterenko
Nicolai Ghiaurov
Nazzereno de Angelis 
Bonaldo Giaiotti
Cesare Siepi
Kurt Moll

I have been fascinated with the bass voice for about twenty years.  I remember my dad playing a recording of "Rigoletto" back then and I was trying to tell the difference between the baritone and the bass.  This list is not ranked in order.  It is based on ten singers I love listening to and who have contributed in significant ways to the field of opera.

Samuel Ramey- The most recorded bass singer in history.  Ramey had a powerful and dark timbre with tremendous bite in the sound when he was in his prime.  He sang all over the world, had a very impressive vocal range, and awesome agility when singing roles by Rossini.  In addition, since he had such an exceptional upper range, Ramey specialized in the early Verdi high bass roles.  He is possibly the greatest Attilla who ever lived combining impressive singing and strong stage presence.  I had the pleasure of hearing Ramey in 2000 as Verdi's King Phillip, and it was very powerful.  Here is Ramey at the height of his powers singing Attilla.
http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=rQZJtOalC9U

Ferruccio Furlanetto, is still active and going very strong at the age of 64.  I was blown away when I heard him live in "Don Carlo" this past March because I wasn't expecting him to be as good as he was.  Furlanetto basically sings everything, and crosses over from comic roles to serious roles very naturally.  For example he was one of the great Leporellos in "Don Giovanni", and sang the role for several decades.  Currently he is a great Don Quichotte in Massenet's "Don Quichotte", which is a very serious role.  When he is interviewed he is a humble man, and very smart with the meaning of the music he sings.  I am sure he has some good years left. Check out the aria from L'Italiana in Algeri on YouTube from January of this year.  He doesn't sound 63 at all in this recording.
http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_2X21u3UPhk

Pol Plancon was one of the first recorded basses in the history of recording.  Luckily he lived when the gramophone was invented, so his art could survive.  Pol Plancon sang all over the world, and was a true lyric bass who used his instrument very wisely.  He was a frequent performer at the Metropolitan Opera, and was most widely known for his portrayal of Mephistopheles in Gounod's "Faust."  My favorite recording of Pol Plancon is his rendition of the Drum Major's Aria by Ambroise Thomas.  His coloratura is magnificent.
http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=NsJoj4s_f4U

Ezio Pinza was perhaps the most famous bass who ever lived.  He had a beautiful and clear timbre with a tremendous forward resonance.  He was a Met regular for several decades, and many of his recordings are available on records and CDs.  He was most famous for roles such as Figaro, and Don Giovanni.  He also excelled in Verdi operas, and French operas such as Faust and "The Tales of Hoffmann."  Pinza's tremendous popularity, charisma and good looks made him a sensation on Broadway as well.  He is Emile Debecque on the original cast recording of "South Pacific."  Pinza was a basso cantabile, but he had a very nice low range down to low d.  Listen to his recording of "Le Cor" by Flegier.  His low D at the end is very strong, and that note isn't an easy one.
http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=7eGY4h1PtNk


Evgeny Nesterenko is still alive, and was still singing as of 2008.   Nesterenko is currently most active as a teacher and competition judge in Russia.  Nesterenko sang repertoire in Russian, French and Italian, and is one of the greatest portrayers of Boris Godunov in history.  Nesterenko was without a doubt a heavy bass in his prime, but could also sing with great nuance and agility.  He was insanely popular in Russia.  Just watch his recital on YouTube.  The audience goes crazy over everything he performs.  He premiered several Shostakovich works such as the 14th and the Sonnets of Micelangelo.  He is on recordings of Nabucco, Faust and Il Trovatore. He is spectacular in all of them,  but his portrayal of Boris really stands out for me.  He sings the role as if he is a Shakespearean actor with tremendous nuance.  Here is Nesterenko singing Boris's death scene.
http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=kyhRB-eXY8k


Nicolai Ghiaurov was one of the most versatile basses of the later half of the 20th century.  Ghiaurov had a stellar legato and was all about the musical phrase.  His voice could be very lyrical, and also very powerful.  His portrayal of King Phillip is one of the greatest of all time.  He recorded it several times and sang it all over the world, including multiple times at the Met.  Ghiaurov was also stunning as Gremin in "Eugene Onegin."  His great sense of the musical line works brilliantly in Gremin's Aria.  In addition he was one of the great portrayers of Mozart's Don Giovanni when he was young.  Like Pinza, Ghaiurov was very popular for a bass.  Audiences all over the world loved him.  Here is Gremin's aria.
http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=wDEdULgViN8

Nazzareno de Angelis had a trumpet like bass voice, but could also sing very softly and lyrically.  The timbre was a high bass because of his fantastic top notes, but the size of his voice was unmistakable.  His portrayal of Boito's Mefistofele is brilliant.  Fortunately he recorded the entire role, and despite him being past his prime, it is still just fantastic.  The top notes in particular are just monstrous.  What's most unique about it is just simply everything.  de Angelis mainly excelled in early Verdi, and other bel canto repertoire. But he also sang Wotan in Wagner's Ring.  Here is de Angelis singing some of his signature role, Mefistofele.  
http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=XUZAFHZWwHY

Bonaldo Giaiotti is not as famous as he should be in my opinion.  However, he is up there with the all time greatest basses because of his powerful and clear timbre.  His top voice was very strong when he was in his prime.  His recording of the role of Walter in "Luisa Miller" is unstoppable.  His Italian diction is a model for singers to listen to.  Listening to his diction not only is helpful with Italian diction, but a good model for healthy singing.  Giaiotti sang well into his 70s.  His prime was the late 1960s through the 1980s, but he was still singing well into old age.  Giaiotti's bread and butter was the Italian belcanto repertoire from Rossini to early Verdi.  However, he did venture into mature Verdi, some verismo, and French opera, such as "Le Cid" by Massenet.  Here is Giaiotti singing "Un Ignoto" from "I Masnadieri" by Verdi.
http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=XUZAFHZWwHY


Cesare Siepi was an excellent Don Giovanni, and was probably most known for that role.  He had a very dark and impressive timbre with a very wide range from low c to high f sharp.  He sang Italian bel canto rep, mature Verdi, French opera, verismo opera, art song, and Broadway show tunes.  Siepi sang well into his 60s and was famous as a recitalist of art song through the end of his career.  Here is Siepi singing some Don Giovanni.
http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=8MXQ-gUrrs0



 Kurt Moll was a very smart German bass who I would call a lyric basso profondo, or lyric deep bass.  Moll was one of the most famous portrayers of Sarastro in "The Magic Flute" and Osmin in "Abduction from the Seraglio." Moll excelled in Osmin's famous aria with the sustained low d without any problem.  His recording of that role from 1971 on Deutsch Gramaphone is as good as it gets.  Although German is his native language, Moll's diction in that recording is clear as a bell, and vocally he couldn't be better.  Moll continued to sing Osmin until he was 65.  Moll also ventured into Italian rep and his bright forward sound worked very well in that repertoire.  He even recorded Monterone in "Rigoletto" which is either a dramatic baritone or a bass baritone.  Here is Moll singing some Osmin.  Moll'slow notes were booming in person. 
http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=hWIBh5vUD34

18 comments:

  1. SO nice to see Pol Plancon get a mention...one of the best, often ignored.

    No Kipnis? :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. I was surprised for not even mentioning Boris Christoff. Indiesputably greatest of all.

    ReplyDelete
  3. These are the 10 that came to mind. Kipnis and Christoff are certainly great too.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The problem with Kurt Moll's interpretation of Osmin is, he sounds way too smart. He's totally unable to play stupid characters. He always sounds like what he is: a natural musical genius. This is also a problem with his Hunding and Baron Ochs.

    Your list of great basses is woefully incomplete. It is missing Matti Salminen, Josef Greindl, Herbert Alsen, Boris Christoff, and Ludwig Weber.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'm surprised. Had you not mentioned Kurt Moll, I might have assumed you were only listing deep bass-baritones but not necessarily bassi profundi. However, since bassi profundi are obviously in play here, hey, were is the deepest, blackest bass of them all: Gottlob Frick ? To me, Frick always sounded like a thunderstorm in a dark forest at midnight ! Plus, he was able to sing Wagner as well, AND buffo roles, too (Bartered Bride, Lustigen Weiber von Windsor).

    Just my 2 cents.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Frick was unbelievable. As was Greindl and Ludwig Weber. I would call Nesterenko at profondo. He had powerful low b flats

      Delete
  6. Don`t forget Feodor Chaliapin, For me is the greatest bass in history.. listen to his Boris Godunov, number two are Mark Reizen

    ReplyDelete
  7. I should maybe list 20 basses next time. All the basses which I did not list that everyone mentioned were great.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I saw the list. Yeah, it is always doubt about listed people are they that good, or not. They all really are brilliant. But...without names such is Christoff, Chalapine and Reizen...please...

      Delete
    2. Surprised nobody mentioned Martti Talvela. In case you had not seen this definitely worth listening: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sdmjz_WBr1w

      Josef Greindl and Martti Talvela sing The Inquisitor Scene from Verdi's Don Carlo

      Delete
    3. Talvela may have been great if you were in the front row seats but when I heard him sing Boris at the Met the voice just didn’t project very well to the nosebleed seats and seemed rather wooly. I was disappointed.

      Delete
  8. Yes all of those ad well as Jerome Hines and Norman Treigle.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anyone who ever had the privilege to see Norman Treigle perform a Mephistopheles in the Boito knew they were seeing greatness. And Hines also had a tremendous vocal range and was equally as great a Attila as was Ramey. better voice in my opinion. There are so many variables involved in a question like this. But I think if you try to take all of them into consideration and boil it all down placing your voice as preeminent, just that a C there are so many variables involved in a question like this. But I think if you try to take all of them into consideration and boil it all down placing your voice as preeminent, Cesare Siepi In a class by himself.

      Delete
  9. Some more greats:

    Giulio Neri (what a powerful Grand Inquisitor!)

    Matti Salminen, probably the best Hagen I have ever heard

    Sir John Tomlinson, my all-time favourite Claggart

    Eric Halfvarson, another wonderful Hagen and - it seems like he does the Grand Inquisitor *everywhere* in the last 20 or so years

    Mihály Székely, while his international career was not long (because he was trapped behind the Iron Curtain from the fifties), had sung Fiesco and Hunding at the Met and Osmin in Glyndebourne. He was legendary as King Philip, Bluebeard, Sarastro and Ochs.

    And while we're at Hungarian basses, László Polgár was another remarkable one - again, a wonderful King Philip, Leporello and Sarastro.

    ReplyDelete